Skip to Main Content

Anthony Awards

Among the most prized awards in the world of mystery writers, the Anthony Awards were named after Anthony Boucher, a mystery & crime fiction author, editor, and critics, who was also a found of the Mystery Writers of America

2000-2009

2000

As an ode to the end of the 20th century, several special one-time awards for "best of the century" were also included during this award ceremony.

In a Dry Season / Peter Robinson


Nominees

  • River of Darkness / Rennie Airth
  • Bones / Jan Burke
  • L.A. Requiem / Robert Crais
  • High Five / Janet Evanovich

Murder, With Peacocks / Donna Andrews


Nominees

  • Murder in the Marais / Cara Black
  • Circles of Confusion / April Henry
  • Reveng of the Gypsy Queen / Kris Neri
  • Inner City Blues / Paula Woods

In Big Trouble / Laura Lippman


Nominees

  • Every Move She Makes / Robin Burcell
  • Lucky Man / Tony Dunbar
  • The Outcast / Jose Latour
  • An Antidote for Avarice / Caroline Rice

Detecting Women, 3rd ed. / Willetta L. Heising


Nominees

  • The Mystery Review Magazine / Barbara Davey, ed.
  • Deadly Pleasure Magazine / George Easter, ed.
  • Ross MacDonald / Tom Nolan
  • Teller of Tales : the Life of Arthur Conan Doyle / Daniel Stashower

Hercule Poirot / Agatha Christie


Nominees

  • 87th Precinct / Ed McBain
  • Sharon McCone / Marcia Muller
  • Lord Peter Wimsey / Dorothy L. Sayers
  • Nero Wolfe / Rex Stout

Agatha Christie


Nominees

  • Raymond Chandler
  • Dashiell Hammett
  • Dorothy L. Sayers
  • Rex Stout

Rebecca / Daphne du Maurier


Nominees

  • The Big Sleep / Raymond Chandler
  • Gaudy Night / Dorothy L. Sayers
  • The Maltese Falcon / Dashiell Hammett
  • The Murder of Roger Ackroyd / Agatha Christie



Jane Langton

2001

A Place of Execution / Val McDermid


Nominees

  • Deep South / Nevada Barr
  • The Bottoms / Joe R. Lansdale
  • Listen to the Silence / Marcia Muller
  • He Shall Thunder in the Sky / Elizabeth Peters
  • Legacy of the Dead / Charles Todd


Death of a Red Heroine / Qiu Xiaolong


Nominees

  • Black Dog / Stephen Booth
  • A Conspiracy of Paper / David Liss
  • The Ice Harvest / Scott Phillips
  • Street Level / Bob Truluck
  • Run / Douglas E. Winter

Death Dances to a Reggae Beat / Kate Grilley


Nominees

  • Bad to the Bone / Katy Munger
  • The Floating Lady Murder / Daniel Stashower
  • Killing Kin / Chassie L. West
  • A Little Death / Laura A. Wilson
  • Te Kidnapping of Rosie Dawn / Eric Wright

Master's Choice, II / Lawrence Block, ed.


Nominees

  • Malice Domestic 9 / Joan Hess, ed.
  • Magnolias and Mayhem / Jeffrey Marks, ed.
  • Unholy Orders / Serita Stevens, ed.
  • Tales Out of School / Carolyn Wheat

100 Favorite Mysteries of the Century / Jim Huang, ed.


Nominees

  • The Complete Christie : an Agatha Christie Encyclopedia / Matthew Bunson
  • Women of Mystery : the Lives and Works of Notable Women Crime Novelists / Martha Hailey DuBose
  • The American Regional Mystery / Marvin Lachman
  • Hard-Boiled : Working Class Readers and Pulp Magazines / Erin A. Smith

Edward D. Hoch

2002

Mystic River / Dennis Lehane


Nominees

  • Flight / Jan Burke
  • Tell No One / Harlan Coben
  • The Devil Went Down to Austin / Rick Riordan
  • Reflecting the Sky / S. J. Rozan


Open Season / C. J. Box


Nominees

  • Third Person Singular / K. J. Erickson
  • Austin City Blue / Jan Grape
  • The Jasmine Trade / Denise Hamilton
  • A Witness Above / Andy Straka

Dead Until Dark / Charlaine Harris


Nominees

  • A Kiss Gone Bad / Jeff Abbott
  • Dim Sum Dead / Jerrilyn Farmer
  • Dead of Winter / P. J. Parrish
  • The Houdini Specter / Daniel Stashower

Seldom Disappointed : a Memoir / Tony Hillerman


Nominees

  • The History of Mystery / Max Allan Collins
  • Dashiell Hammett : a Daughter Remembers / Jo Hammett
  • Writing the Mystery : a Start to Finish Guide for Both Novice and Professional / G. Miki Hayden
  • Who Was That Lady? : Craig Rice : the Queen of Screwball Mystery / Jeffrey Marks

The Mystery of the Haunted Caves / Penny Warner


Nominees

  • The Viking Claw / Michael Dahl
  • Death on Sacred Ground / Harriet R. Feder
  • Ghost Sitter / Peni Griffin
  • Web / Jeri Fink

2003

City of Bones / Michael Connelly


Nominees

  • Murder in the Sentier / Cara Black
  • North of Nowhere / Steve Hamilton
  • Hell To Pay / George P. Pelecanos
  • Winter and Night / S. J. Rozan

In the Bleak Midwinter / Julia Spencer


Nominees

  • The Devil's Redhead / David Corbett
  • An Eye for Murder / Libby Fischer
  • The Blue Edge of Midnight / Jonathon King
  • The Distance / Eddie Muller

Fatal Truth / Robin Burcell


Nominees

  • Black Jack Point / Jeff Abbott
  • Six Strokes Under / Roberta Isleib
  • Paint It Black / P. J. Parrish
  • A Killing Sky / Andy Straka

They Died in Vain : Overlooked, Underappreciated, and Forgotten Mystery Novels / Jim Huang, ed.


Nominees

  • The Mammoth Encyclopedia of Modern Crime Fiction / Mike Ashley, ed.
  • Intent to Sell : Marketing the Genre Novel / Jeffrey Marks

2004

Every Secret Thing / Laura Lippman


Nominees

  • The Delicate Storm / Giles Blunt
  • Blood is the Sky / Steve Hamilton
  • Shutter Island / Dennis Lehane
  • The Summer That Never Was/Close to Home / Peter Robinson

Monkeewrench / P. J. Tracy


Nominees

  • Haunted Ground / Erin Hart
  • Death of a Nationalist / Rebecca Pawel
  • Wiley's Lament / Lorio Waiwaiole
  • Maisie Dobbs / Jacqueline Winspear

Deadly Legacy / Robin Burcell


Nominees

  • Dealing in Murder / Elaine Flinn
  • Thicker Than Water / P. J. Parrish
  • Tough Luck / Jason Starr
  • Find Me Again / Sylvia Maultash Warsh

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix / J. K. Rowling


Nominees

  • Artemis Fowl : the Eternity Code / Eoin Colfer
  • Feast of Fools / Bridget Crowley
  • Seventh Knot / Kathleen Karr
  • No Escape / Norah McClintock

For the Love of Mike / Rhys Bowen


Nominees

  • Let Loose the Dogs / Maureen Jennings
  • The Bridge of Sighs / Olen Steinhauer
  • Find Me Again / Sylvia Maultash Warsh
  • Maisie Dobbs / Jacqueline Winspear

Make Mine a Mystery : a Reader's Guide to Mystery and Detective Fiction / Gary Warren Niebuhr


Nominees

  • Mystery Women : an Eneyclopedia of Leading Women Characters in Mystery Fiction, Volume III / Colleen Barnett
  • The Story of Jane Doe : a Book About Rape / Jane Doe
  • Interrogations / Jon Jordan
  • Beautiful Shadow : a Life of Patricia Highsmith / Andrew Wilson

2005

Blood Hollow / William Kent Krueger


Nominees

  • The Killing of the tinkers / Ken Bruen
  • The Madman's Tale / John Katzenbach
  • By a Spider's Thread / Laura Lippman
  • California Girl / T. Jefferson Parker
  • Out of the Deep I Cry / Julia Spencer-Fleming

Dating Dead Men / Harley Jane Kozak


Nominees

  • Uncommon Grounds / Sandra Balzo
  • Until the Cows Come Home / Judy Clemens
  • Retribution / Jilliane P. Hoffman
  • Whiskey Sour / J. A. Konrath

Twisted City / Jason Starr


Nominees

  • Cold Case / Robin Burcell
  • Putt to Death / Roberta Isleib
  • Blue Blood / Susan McBride
  • The Halo Effect / M. J. Rose

Men's Adventure Magazines / Max Allan Collins


Nominees

  • Famous American Crimes & Trials / Frankie Bailey, Steven Chermak
  • Blue Blood / Edward Conlon
  • The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes / Leslie S. Klinger, ed.
  • The Ballad of the Whiskey Robber / Julian Rubinstein

Bill Pronzini

Marcia Muller

2006

Mercy Falls / William Kent Krueger


Nominees

  • Bloodlines / Jan Burke
  • The Lincoln Lawyer / Michael Connelly
  • Red Leaves / Thomas H. Cook
  • To the Power of Three / Laura Lippman

Tilt-A-Whirl / Chris Grabenstein


Nominees

  • Die a Little / Megan Abbot
  • Immoral / Brian Freeman
  • The Baby Game / Randall Hicks
  • Officer Down / Theresa Schwegel

The James Deans / Reed Farrel Coleman


Nominees

  • Kiss Her Goodbye / Allan Guthrie
  • Six Bad Things / Charlie Huston
  • Good Girl's Guide to Murder / Susan McBride
  • A Killing Rain / P. J. Parrish

The Heirs of Anthony Boucher / Marv Lachman


Nominees

  • Writing and Selling Your Mystery Novel / Hallie Ephron
  • Behind the Mystery / Stuart Kaminsky
  • New Annotated Sherlock Holmes / Leslie Klinger
  • Girl Sleuth : Nancy Drew and the Women Who Created Here / Melanie Rehak

Robert B. Parker

Note:  Robert B. Parker died in 2010, but the Spenser series of books has continued under another writer.  Only those written directly by Robert B. Parker will be included in this list, although the library does own most, if not all, the continuation of the series written by Ace Atkins.  Most of those titles begin with "Robert B. Parker's..." and show Parker as the main author in case you are interested in reading them.

2007

No Good Deeds / Laura Lippman


Nominees

  • Kidnapped / Jan Burke
  • The Dead Hour / Denise Mina
  • The Virgin of Small Plains / Nancy Pickard
  • All Mortal Flesh / Julia Spencer-Fleming

Still Life / Louise Penny


Nominees

  • The King of Lies / John Hart
  • Holmes on the Range / Steve Hockensmith
  • A Field of Darkness / Cornelia Read
  • The Harrowing / Alexandra Sokoloff

Ashes and Bones / Dana Cameron


Nominees

  • 47 Rules of HIghly Effective Bank Robbers / Troy Cook
  • The Cleanup / Sean Doolittle
  • Baby Shark / Robert Fate
  • Shotgun Opera / Victor Gischler
  • Snakeskin Shamisen / Naomi Hirahara
  • A Dangerous Man / Charlie Huston

Mystery Muses / Jim Huang & Austin Lugar


Nominees

  • Read 'Em Their Writes / Gary Warren Niebuhr
  • Don't Murder Your Mystery / Chris Roerden
  • The Beautiful Cigar Girl / Daniel Stashower
  • The Science of Sherlock Holmes / E. J. Wagner

James Sallis

2008

What the Dead Know / Laura Lippman


Nominees

  • Tin Roof Blowdown / James lee Burke
  • Bad Luck and Trouble / Lee Child
  • The Watchman / Robert Crais
  • Thunder Bay / William Kent Krueger


In the Woods / Tana French


Nominees

  • Big City, Bad Blood / Sean Chercover
  • The Spellman Files / Lisa Lutz
  • Head Games / Craig McDonald
  • The Blade Itself / Marcus Sakey

A Thousand Bones / P. J. Parrish


Nominees

  • Queenpin / Megan Abbott
  • Slide / Ken Bruen and Jason Starr
  • Blood of Paradise / David Corbett
  • Baby Shark's Beaumont Blues / Robert Fate

Arthur Conan Doyle : a Life in Letters / Jon Lellenberg, Daniel Stashower & Charles Foley


Nominees

  • The Essential Mystery Lists / Roger Sobin
  • The Triumph of the Thriller : How Cops, Crooks and Cannibals Captured Popular Fiction / Patrick Anderson
  • Deviance in Contemporary Crime Fiction / Christiana Gregoriou

Robert Rosenwald and Barbara G. Peters

2009

The Brass Verdict / Michael Connelly


Nominees

  • Trigger City / Sean Chercover
  • Red Knife / William Kent Krueger
  • The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo / Stieg Larsson
  • The Cruelest Month / Louise Penny

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo / Stieg Larsson


Nominees

  • Pushing Up Daisies / Rosemary Harris
  • Stalking Susan / Julie Kramer
  • Death of a Cozy Writer / G. M. Malliet
  • Child 44  / Tom Rob Smith

State of the Onion / Julie Hyzy


Nominees

  • The First Quarry / Max Allan Collins
  • Money Shot / Christa Faust
  • In a Dark Season / Vicki Lane
  • South of Hell / P. J. Parrish

Anthony Boucher : a Biobibliography / Jeffrey Marks


Nominees

  • African American Mystery Writers : a Historical and Thematic Study / Frankie Y. Bailey
  • How to Write Killer Historical Mysteries / Kathy Lynn Emerson
  • The Suspicions of Mr. Whicher : a Shocking Murder and the Undoing of a Great Victorian Detective / Kate Summerscale

The Crossroads / Chris Grabenstein


Nominees

  • Paper Towns / John Green
  • Kiss Me, Kill Me / Lauren Henderson
  • The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey / Trenton Lee Stewart
  • Sammy Keyes and the Cold Hard Cash / Wendelin Van Draanen


Allen J. Hubin