Skip to Main Content

Anthony Awards

Among the most prized awards in the world of mystery writers, the Anthony Awards were named after Anthony Boucher, a mystery & crime fiction author, editor, and critics, who was also a found of the Mystery Writers of America

2010-2019

2010

The Brutal Telling / Louise Penny


Nominees

  • The Last Child / John Hart
  • The Mystic Arts of Erasing All Signs of Death / Charlie Huston
  • The Girl Who Played With Fire / Stieg Larsson, translated by Reg Keeland
  • The Shanghai Moon / S. J. Rozan

A Bad Day for Sorry / Sophie Littlefield


Nominees

  • The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie / Alan Bradley
  • Starvation Lake / Bryan Gruley
  • The Twelve / The Ghosts of Belfast / Stuart Neville
  • In the Shadow of Gotham / Stafanie Pintoff

Starvation Lake / Bryan Gruley


Nominees

  • Bury Me Deep / Megan Abbott
  • Tower / Ken Bruen and Reed Farrel Coleman
  • Quarry in the Middle / Max Allan Collins
  • Death and the Lit Chick / G. M. Malliet
  • Air Time / Hank Phillippi Ryan

Talking About Detective Fiction / P. D. James


Nominees

  • The Line Up : the World's Greatest Crime Writers Tell the Inside Story of Their Greatest Detectives / Otto Penzler, ed.
  • Haunted Heart : the Life and Times of Stephen Kin / Lisa Rogak
  • Dame Agatha's Shorts : an Agatha Christie Short Story Companion / Elena Santagelo
  • The Talented Mrs. Highsmith : the Secret Life and Serious Art of Patricia Highsmith / Joan Schenkar

2011

Bury Your Dead / Louise Penny


Nominees

  • Crooked Letter, Crooked Letter / Tom Franklin
  • Faithful Place / Tana French
  • The Lock Artist / Steve Hamilton
  • I'd Know You Anywhere / Laura Lippman


Damage Done / Hilary Davidson


Nominees

  • Rogue Island / Bruce DeSilva
  • Poacher's Son / Paul Doiron
  • The Sherlockian / Graham Moore
  • Snow Angels / James Thompson

Expiration Date / Duane Swierczynski


Nominees

  • Long Time Coming / Robert Goddard
  • The Hanging Tree / Bryan Gruley
  • Drive Time / Hank Phillipp Ryan
  • Vienna Secrets / Frank Tallis

The Chill / Jason Starr


Nominees

  • Scalped Volume 6 : The Gnawing / Jason Aaron
  • Richard Stark's Parker, Volume 2 : the Outfit / Darwyn Cooke
  • Tumor / Joshua Hale Fialkov, Noel Tuzaon
  • Sickness in the Family / Denise Mina
  • Beasts of Burden / Jill Thompson, Evan Dorkin

Agatha Christie's Secret Notebooks / John Curran


Nominees

  • The Wire : Truth Be Told / Rafael Alvarez
  • Sherlock Holmes for Dummies / Steven Doyle, David A. Crowder
  • Charlie Chan : the Untold Story of the Honorable Detective and His Rendezvous with American History / Yunte Huang
  • Thrillers : 100 Must Reads / David Morrell

Sara Paretsky

2012

A Trick of the Light / Louise Penny


Nominees

  • The End of Everything / Megan Abbott
  • Hurt Machine / Reed Farrel Coleman
  • The Drop / Michael Connelly
  • One Was a Soldier / Julia Spencer-Fleming

Learning to Swim / Sara J. Henry


Nominees

  • Nazareth Child / Darrell James
  • All Cry Chaos / Leonard Rose
  • Who Do, Voodoo? / Rochell Staab
  • The Informationist / Taylor Stevens
  • Purgatory Chasm / Steve Ulfelder
  • Before I Go to Sleep / S. J. Watson

Buffalo West Wing / Julie Hyzy


Nominees

  • The Company Man / Robert Jackson Bennett
  • Choke Hold / Christa Faust
  • Death of the Mantis / Michael Stanley
  • Fun & Games / Duane Swierczynski
  • Vienna Twilight / Frank Tallis

The Sookie Stackhouse Companion Charlaine Harris, ed.


Nominees

  • Books, Crooks and Counselors : How to Write Accurately About Criminal Law and Courtroom Procedure / Leslie Budewitz
  • Agatha Christie : Murder in the Making : More Stories and Secrets From Her Notebooks / John Curran
  • On Conan Doyle : or, the Whole Art of Storytelling / Michael Dirda
  • Detecting Women : Gender and the Hollywood Detective Film / Philippa Gates

2013

The Beautiful Mystery / Louise Penny


Nominees

  • Dare Me / Megan Abbott
  • The Trinity Game / Sean Chercover
  • Gone Girl / Gillian Flynn
  • The Other Woman / Hank Phillipp Ryan

The Expats / Chris Pavone


Nominees

  • Don't Ever Get Old / Daniel Friedman
  • The Professionals / Owen Laukkanen
  • The 500 / Matthew Quirk
  • Black Fridays / Michael Sears

Big Maria / Johnny Shaw


Nominees

  • Whiplash River / Lou Berney
  • Murder for Choir / Joelle Charbonneau
  • And She Was / Alison Gaylin
  • Blessed are the Dead / Malia Nunn

Books to Die For : the World's Greatest Mystery Writers on the World's Greatest Mystery Novels / John Connolly and Declan Burke, eds.


Nominees

  • Blood Relations : the Selected Letters of Ellery Queen, 1947-1950 / Joseph Goodrich, ed.
  • More Forensics and Fiction : Crime Writers Morbidly Curious Questions Expertly Asnwered / D. P. Lyle
  • The Grand Tour : Around the World with the Queen of Mystery Agatha Christie / Mathew Prichard, ed.
  • In Pursuit of Spenser : Mystery Writers on Robert B. Parker and the Creation of an American Hero / Otto Penzler, ed.

2014

Ordinary Grace / William Kent Krueger


Nominees

  • Suspect / Robert Crais
  • A Cold and Lonely Place / Sara J. Henry
  • The Wrong Girl / Hank Phillipp Ryan
  • Through the Evil Days / Julia Spencer-Fleming

Yesterday's Echo / Matt Coyle


Nominees

  • Ghostman / Roger Hobbs
  • Rage Against the Dying / Becky Masterman
  • Reconstructing Amelia / Kimberly McCreight
  • The Hard Bounce / Todd Robinson

As She Left It / Catriona McPherson


Nominees

  • The Big Reap / Chris F. Holm
  • Purgatory Key / Darrell James
  • Joyland / Stephen King
  • The Wicked Girls / Alex Marwood

The Hour of Peril : the Secret Plot to Murder Lincoln Before the Civil War / Daniel Stashower


Nominees

  • Mastermind : How to Think Like Sherlock Holmes / Maria Konnikova
  • The Secret Rescue :an Untold Story of American Nurses and Medics Behind Nazi Lines / Cate Lineberry
  • All the Wild Children / Josh Stallings
  • Troubled Daughters, Twisted Wives : Stories from the Trailblazers of Domestic Suspense / Sarah Weinman, ed.

The Testing / Joelle Charbonneau


Nominees

  • Escape Theory / Margaux Froley
  • Escape from Mr. Lemoncello's Library / Chris Grabenstein
  • Dancer, Daughter, Traitor, Spy / Elizabeth Kiem
  • The Code Buster's Club : Mystery of the Pirate's Treasure / Penny Warner

The Cuckoo's Calling / Robert Galbraith


Nominees

  • Hour of the Rat / Lisa Brackman ; Tracy Sallows, narrator
  • Man in the Empty Suit / Sean Ferrll ; Mauro Hantman, narrator
  • Crescendo / Deborah J. Ledford ; Christina Cox, narratory
  • Death and the Lit Chick / G. M. Malliet ; Davina Porter, narrator

2015

After I'm Gone / Laura Lippman


Nominees

  • Lamentation / Joe Clifford
  • The Secret Place / Tana French
  • Te Long Way Home / Louise Penny
  • Truth Be Told / Hank Phillippi Ryan

The Black Hour / Lori Rader-Day


Nominees

  • Blessed Are the Dead / Kristi Belcamino
  • Ice Shear / M. P. Cooley
  • Invisible City / Julia Dahl
  • The Life We Bury / Allen Eskens

The Day She Died / Catriona McPherson


Nominees

  • Stay With Me / Alison Gaylin
  • The Killer Next Door / Alex Marwood
  • World of Trouble / Ben H. Winters
  • No Stone Unturned / James W. Ziskin

Writes of Passage : Adventures on the Writer's Journey / Hank Phillippi Ryan, ed.


Nominees

  • The Figure of the Detective : a Literary HIstory and Analysis / Charles Brownson
  • Death Dealer : How Cops and Cadaver Dogs Brought a Killer to Justice / Kate Clark Flora
  • Dru's Book Musings / Dru Ann Lov
  • Poe-Land : the Hallowed Haunts of Edgar Allan Poe / J. W. Ocker

In the Company of Sherlock Holmes : Stories Inspired by the Holmes Canon / Laurie R. King & Leslie S. Klinger, eds.


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

2016

The Killing Kind / Chris Holm


Nominees

  • Night Tremors / Matt Coyle
  • The Child Garden / Catriona McPherson
  • The Nature of the Beast / Louise Penny
  • What You See / Hank Phillipp Ryan

Past Crimes / Glen Erik Hamilton


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

The Long and Faraway Gone / Lou Berney


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Forensics : What Bugs, Burns, Prints, DNA, and More Tell Us About Crime / Val McDermid


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Murder Under the Oaks : Bouchercon Anthology 2015 / Art Taylor, ed.


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Need / Joelle Charbonneau


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

The Nature of the Beast / Louise Penny ; Robert Bathurst, narrator

2017

A Great Reckoning / Louise Penny


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

IQ / Joe Ide


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Heart of Stone / James W. Ziskin


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Blood on the Bayou : Bouchercon Anthology 2016 / Greg Herren, ed.


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

The Girl I Used to Be / April Henry


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Shirley Jackson : a Rather Haunted Life / Ruth Franklin


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

2018

Bluebird, Bluebird / Attica Locke


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Hollywood Homicide / Kellye Garrett


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

The Day I Died / Lori Rader-Day


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Y is for Yesterday  (Kinsey Millhone #25) / Sue Grafton


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

The Obama Inheritance : Fifteen Stories of Conspiracy Noir / Gary Phillips, ed.


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

Killers of the Flower Moon : the Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI / David Grann


Nominees

  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title
  • Title

2019

November Road / Lou Berney


Nominees

  • Give Me Your Hand / Megan Abbott
  • Jar of Hearts / Jennifer Hillier
  • Sunburn / Laura Lippman
  • Blackout / Alex Segura



My Sister, the Serial Killer / Oyinkan Braithwaite


Nominees

  • Broken Places / Tracy Clark
  • Dodging and Burning / John Copenhaver
  • What Doesn't Kill You / Aimee Hix
  • Bearskin / James A. McLaughlin

Under a Dark Sky / Lori Rader-Day


Nominees

  • Hollywood Ending / Kellye Garrett
  • If I Die Tonight / Alison Gaylin
  • Hiroshima Boy / Naomi Hirahara
  • A Stone's Throw / James W. Ziskin

I'll Be Gone in the Dark : One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer / Michelle McNamara


Nominees

  • Dead Girls : Essays on Surviving an American Obsession / Alice Bolin
  • Mastering Plot Twists : How to Use Suspense, Targeted Storytelling Strategies, and Structure to Captivate Your Readers / Jane K. Cleland
  • Pulp According to David Goodis / Jay A. Gertzman
  • Classic American Crime Fiction of the 1920s / Leslie S. Klinger
  • The Real Lolita : the Kidnapping of Sally Horner and the Novel That Scandalized the World / Sarah Weinman