Skip to Main Content

Anthony Awards

Among the most prized awards in the world of mystery writers, the Anthony Awards were named after Anthony Boucher, a mystery & crime fiction author, editor, and critics, who was also a found of the Mystery Writers of America

1990-1999

1990

The Sirens Sang of Murder  by Sarah Caudwell

Nominees

  • Pious Deception / Susan Dunlap
  • A Little Class on Murder / Carolyn G. Hart
  • Corpus Christmas / Margaret Maron

Katwalk  by Karen Kijewski

Nominees

  • Grime and Punishment / Jill Churchill
  • The Mother Shadow / Melodie Johnson Howe
  • The Mark Twain Murders / Edith Skom
  • The Last Billable Hour / Susan Wolfe

Honeymoon with Murder  by Carolyn Hart

Nominees

  • On My Honor / Malacai Black (Barbara D'Amato)
  • Murder By Deception / D. R. Meredith
  • Rough Justice / Keith Peterson
  • A Collector of Photographs / Deborah Valentine

Michael Gilbert

1991

G is for Gumshoe  by Sue Grafton

Nominees

  • A Ticket to the Boneyard / Lawrence Block
  • The Good Fight / Lia Matera
  • If Ever I Return, Pretty Peggy-O / Sharyn McCrumb
  • New Orleans Mourning / Julie Smith

Postmortem  by Patricia Cornwell

Nominees

  • Catering to Nobody / Diane Mott Davidson
  • Kindred Crimes / Janet Dawson
  • Where's Mommy Now? / Rochelle Krich
  • Grave Undertaking / James McCahery

Grave Undertaking  by James McCahery

Where's Mommy Now?   by Rochelle Krich

Nominees

  • Not a Creature Was Stirring / Jane Haddam
  • Dead in the Scrub / G. J. Oliphant
  • Sisters in Crime 2 / Marilyn Wallace

Synod of Sleuths : Essays on Judeo-Christian Detective Fiction  by Jon L. Breen & Martin H. Greenberg

Nominees

  • Deadly Doses : a Writer's Guide to Poisons / Serita Deborah Stevens, with Anne Klarner
  • Eric Ambler / Peter Lewis
  • John Dickson Carr : a Critical Study / S. T. Joshi
  • Trouble is Their Business : Private Eyes in Fiction, Film & Television, 1927-1988 / John Conquest

William Campbell Gault

1992

The Last Detective  by Peter Lovesey

Nominees

  • Rogue Wave / Susan Dunlap
  • Love Nor Money / Linda Grant
  • Hour of the Hunter / J. A. Jance
  • I. O. U. / Nancy Pickard
  • A Single Stone / Marilyn Wallace

Murder on the Iditarod Trail  by Sue Henry

Nominees

  • Carpool / Mary Cahill
  • A Relative Stranger / Margaret Lucke
  • The Bulrush Murders / Rebecca Rothenberg
  • The Chocolate Box / Leslie Watts
  • Murder on the Run / Gloria White

Homicide : a Year on the Killing Streets / David Simon

Nominees

  • And the Sea Will Tell / Vincent Bugliosi with Bruce B. Henderson
  • Sins of the Father : the Landmark Franklin Case : a Daughter, a Memory, and a Murder / Eileen Franklin, William Wright
  • Witnesses From the Grave : the Stories Bones Tell / Christopher Joyce
  • Plausible Denial / Mark Lane
  • Cruel Doubt / Joe McGinniss

A Woman's Eye / Sara Paretsky, ed.

Nominees

  • Cat Crimes / Martin H. Greenberg, Ed Gorman, eds.
  • Alfred Hitchcock's Home Sweet Homicide / Cahtleen Jordan, ed.
  • Christmas Stalkings : Tales of Yuletide Murder / Charlotte MacLoeod, ed.
  • Fifty Years of the Best From Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine / Eleanor Sullivan, ed.
  • Sisters in Crime 4 / Marilyn Wallace, ed.

100 Great Detectives  by Maxim Jakubowski

Nominees

  • Locked Room Murders / Robert Adey
  • Out of the Woodpile / Frankie Y. Bailey
  • Twentieth Century Crime and Mystery Writers, 3rd ed. / Lesley Henderson
  • Talking Mysteries : a Conversation with Tony Hillerman / Tony Hillerman
  • Jim Thompson : Sleep with the Devil / M. J. McCauley

Charlotte MacLeod

 

1993

Bootlegger's Daughter  by Margaret Maron

Nominees

  • Lullaby Town / Robert Crais
  • Booked to Die / John Dunning
  • Southern Ghost / Carolyn Hart
  • The Hangman's Beautiful Daughter / Sharon McCrumb

Blanche on the Lam  by Barbara Neely

Nominees

  • Thyme of Death / Susan Wittig Albert
  • Decked / Carol Higgins Clark
  • The Black Echo / Michael Connelly
  • The Winter Widow / Charlene Weir

The Doctor, The Murder, The Mystery : the True Story of the Dr. John Branion Murder Case / Barbara D'Amato

Nominees

  • The Trunk Murderess : Winnie Ruth Judd / Jana Bommersbach
  • Blood Echoes : the True Story of an Infamous Mass Murder and Its Aftermath / Thomas H. Cook
  • The Shadow of Death : The Hunt for a Serial Killer / Philip E. Ginsburg
  • Everything She Ever Wanted : a True Story of Obsessive Love, Murder, and Betrayal / Ann Rule

Doubleday Crime Club Compendium 1928-1991  by Ellen Nehr

Nominees

  • Dorothy L. Sayers : a Careless Rage for Life / David Coomes
  • Alias S. S. Van Dine / John Loughery

Hammond Innes and Ralph McInerny

1994

Wolf in the Shadows / Marcia Muller


Nominees

  • The Black Ice / Michael Connelly
  • Morons and Madmen / Earl Emerson
  • O Little Town of Maggody / Joan Hess
  • Sacred Clowns / Tony Hillerman
  • Old Enemies / Janet LaPierre
  • Southern Discomfort / Margaret Maron
  • To Live and Die in Dixie / Kathy Hogan Trocheck
  • The Sculptress / Minette Walters
  • Consider the Crows / Charlene Weir


Track of the Cat / Nevada Barr


Nominees

  • Goodnight, Irene / Jan Burke
  • A Grave Talent / Laurie R. King
  • Death Comes as Epiphany / Sharan Newman
  • Child of Silence / Abigail Padgett

A Rose For Her Grave : and Other True Cases / Ann Rule


Nominees

  • Driven to Kill : Westley Allan Dodd / Gary C. King
  • The Misbegotten Son : a Serial Killer and His Victims : the True Story of Arthur J. Shawcross / Jack Olsen
  • Until the Twelfth of Never : the Deadly Divorce of Dan & Betty Broderick / Bella Stumbo

Mary Higgins Clark Presents Malice Domestic 2 / Martin H. Greenberg, ed.


Nominees

  • Some Days You Get the Bear / Lawrence Block
  • Bohannon's Country / Joseph Hansen
  • The Year's Best Mystery and Suspense Stories 1993 / Ed Hoch, ed.
  • Criminal Intent 1 / Marcia Muller, Ed Gorman, Bill Pronzini

The Fine Art of Murder : the Mystery Reader's Indispensible Companion / Ed Gorman, Martin H. Greenberg, & Larry Segriff


Nominees

  • The Saint : a Complete History in Print, Radio, Film and Television / Burl Barer
  • A Reader's Guide to the American Novel of Detection / Marvin Lachman
  • A Reader's Guide to the Private Eye Novel / Gary Warren Niebuhr
  • Dorothy L. Sayers : Her Life and Soul / Barbara Reynolds

Tony Hillerman

1995

She Walks These Hills / Sharyn McCrumb

Nominees

  • The Concrete Blonde / Michael Connelly
  • Kolymsky Heights / Lionel Davidson
  • One for the Money / Janet Evanovich
  • "K" is for Killer / Sue Grafton
  • Murder on a Kibbutz / Batya Gur
  • Pictures of Perfection / Reginald Hill
  • Cold Shoulder / Lynda La Plante
  • The 13th Juror / John Lescroart
  • Crack Down / Val McDermid
  • Black Betty / Walter Mosley
  • Not Till the Red Fog Rises / Derek Raymond
  • Just a Corpse at Twilight / Janwillem van de Wetering




 

The Alienist / Caleb Carr

Nominees

  • Snow Falling on Cedars / David Guterson
  • Alex Keegan : A Drink Before the War / Dennis Lehane
  • Mallory's Oracle / Carol O'Connell
  • Shinju / Laura Joh Rowland
  • Every Breath You Take / Michelle Spring
  • Big Town / Doug J. Swanson
  • Death of a Blue Lantern / Christopher West

Crime Fiction, 2nd Edition / B. A. Pike & J. Cooper

Nominees

  • Encyclopedia Mysteriosa / William DeAndrea
  • The Tony Hillerman Companion / Martin H. Greenberg
  • The Fatal Art of Entertainment / Rosemary Herbert

The Mysterious West / Tony Hillerman

Nominees

  • Hollywood Nocturnes / James Ellroy
  • A Modern Treasury of Great Detective Stories / Ed Gorman, ed.
  • London Noir / Maxim Jakubowski, ed.
  • Murder for Halloween : Tales of Suspense / Michele Slung, Roland Hartman, eds.

Criminal Shadows : Inside the Mind of the Serial Killer / David Canter

Nominees

  • Shot in the Heart / Mikal Gilmore
  • Dillinger, the Untold Story / G. Russell Giradin with William J. Helmer
  • The Faber Book of Murder / Simon Rae
  • The Complete History of Jack the Ripper / Philip Sugden

Ruth Rendell  (aka, Barbara Vine)

1996

Under the Beetle's Cellar / Mary Willis Walker


Nominees

  • The Last Coyote / Michael Connelly
  • Hard Christmas / Barbara D'Amato
  • True Crime / Andrew Klavan
  • Blue Lonesome / Bill Pronzini

Death in Bloodhound Red / Virginia Lanier


Nominees

  • The Innocents / Richard Barre
  • Who in Hell is Wanda Fuca? / G. M. Ford
  • Hammurabi's Code / Charles Kenney
  • Murder in Scorpio / Martha C. Lawrence

Deal Breaker / Harlan Coben


Nominees

  • Bad Medicine / Eileen Dreyer
  • A Far and Deadly Cry / Teri Holbrook
  • Charged with Guilt / Gloria White
  • Closet / R. D. Zimmerman

The McCone Files : the Complete Sharon McCone Stories / Marcia Muller


Nominees

  • Cat Crimes Takes a Vacation / Martin H. Greenberg, Ed Gorman, eds.
  • Crimes of the Heart / Carolyn G. Hart, ed.
  • Malice Domestic 4 / Carolyn G. Hart, ed.
  • Spooks, Spies, and Private Eyes / Paula L. Woods, ed.

Dead by Sunset : Perfect Husband, Perfect Killer / Ann Rule


Nominees

  • Man Overboard : the Counterfeit Resurrection of Phil Champagne / Burl Barer
  • Mindhunter : Inside the FBI's Elite Serial Crime Unit / John Douglas, Mark Olshaker
  • Circumstantial Evidence : Death, Life, and Justice in a Southern Town / Pete Earley
  • Born to Kill : America's Most Notorious Vietnamese Gang, and the Changing Face of Organized Crime / T. J. English

The Armchair Detective Book of Lists, 2nd ed. / Kate Stine, ed.


Nominees

  • A Gentle Madness : Bibliophiles, Bibliomanes, and the Eternal Passion for Books / Nicholas A. Basbanes
  • John Dickson Carr : the Man Who Explained Miracles / Douglas G. Greene
  • Savage Art : a Biography of Jim Thompson / Robert Polito
  • Ngaio Marsh : the Woman and Her Work / B. J. Rahn, ed.

1997

The Poet / Michael Connelly


Nominees

  • Firestorm / Nevada Barr
  • Lethal Genes / Linda Grant
  • Hearts and Bones / Margaret Lawrence
  • Multiple Wounds / Alan Russell

Tie

  • Death in Little Tokyo / Dale Furutani

  • Somebody Else's Child / Terris McMahan Grimes


Nominees

  • Tularosa / Michael McGarrity
  • A Test of Wills / Charles Todd
  • A Brother's Blood / Michael C. White

Somebody Else's Child / Terris McMahan Grimes


Nominees

  • Fade Away / Harlan Coben
  • The Grass Widow / Teri Holbrook
  • Walking Rain / Susan Wade
  • Chain of Fools / Steven Womack

Detecting Women 2 : Reader's Guide and Checklist for Mystery Series Written by Women / Willetta L. Heising


Nominees

  • Mystery! : a Celebration : Stalking Public Television's Greatest Sleuths / Ron Miller, Karen Sharpe, eds.
  • The Letters of Dorothy L. Sayers 1899-1936 : the Making of a Detective Novelist / Barbara REynolds, ed.
  • By a Woman's Hand : a Guide to Mystery Fiction by Women, 2nd ed. / Jean Swanson, Dean James, eds.

Donald E. Westlake

1998

No Colder Place / S. J. Rozan


Nominees

  • Devil's Food / Anthony Bruno
  • Deception Pass / Earl Emerson
  • The Club Dumas / Arturo Pérez-Reverte
  • Eye of the Cricket / James Sallis

Killing Floor / Lee Child


Nominees

  • If I Should Die / Grace Edwards
  • Except the Dying / Maureen Jennings
  • Bird Dog / Philip Reed
  • Skin Deep, Blood Red / Robert Skinner

Big Red Tequila / Rick Riordan


Nominees

  • Charm City / Laura Lippman
  • The Salaryman's Wife / Sujata Massey
  • 23 Shades of Black/ K. J. A. Wishnia

1999

Blood Work / Michael Connelly


Nominees

  • Blind Descent / Nevada Barr
  • On Beulah Height / Reginald Hill
  • Gone, Baby, Gone / Dennis Lehane
  • Framework for Death / Aileen Schumacher

Iron Lake / William Kent Krueger


Nominees

  • Sympathy for the Devil / Jerrilyn Farmer
  • Tiger's Palette / Jacqueline Fiedler
  • A Cold Day in Paradise / Steve Hamilton
  • Eleven Days / Donald Harstad

Butcher's Hill / Laura Lippman


Nominees

  • Zen Attitude / Sujata Massey
  • The Widower's Two-Step / Rick Riordan
  • Remedy for Treason / Caroline Roe
  • Murder Manual / Steven Womack

Deadly Pleasures Magazine / George Easter, ed.


Nominees

  • Mystery Reader's Walking Guide : Washington, D.C. / Alzina Stone Dale
  • Dark City : the Lost World of Film Noir / Eddie Muller
  • Silk Stalkings : More Women Write of Murder / Victoria Nichols, Susan Thompson
  • Mystery and Suspense Writers : the Literature of Crime, Detection, and Espionage / Robin Winks, Maureen Corrigan, eds.

Len & June Moffatt